Why a growing secondhand market can leave charity shops struggling

More secondhand sales do not necessarily mean stronger charity shops. Valuable clothes can find buyers elsewhere, while the cost of handling unwanted donations remains.

Charity Retail Ireland’s latest report illustrates the pressure. Its members sold around ten million garments in 2025, but also processed more than a million bags of textiles described as unsaleable. The organisation says rising costs and poor-quality donations are squeezing the money available for charitable services.
Behind that pressure may be two changes working together: which clothes people donate, and which textiles collection systems receive.

Online platforms allow owners to sell valuable garments themselves. Those clothes may still be reused, but their value no longer helps fund a charity shop’s handling of other donations.
A British survey commissioned by Rathbones found that 38 per cent of executives at charities operating shops reported declining donation quality since the rise of resale platforms. However, 42 per cent reported no change and 18 per cent an improvement. The findings support a possible shift, rather than a uniform decline across the sector.

A separate change could affect the other end of the quality range. Collecting textiles previously thrown into household bins may bring more damaged or low-value items into collection systems.
Ireland is subject to the EU requirement for separate textile collection from January 2025. Its system includes clothing banks and charity shops, although official guidance tells donors to bring items suitable for reuse. Britain is outside that EU requirement.
These are different collection contexts, and the Irish figures alone do not establish whether broader collection has worsened donation quality.
Both pressures could nevertheless operate together: fewer valuable donations to sell, alongside more material requiring costly handling.

There is another distinction behind the waste headlines. Clothing that does not sell in one shop may still have buyers elsewhere. In its Irish policy submission, Charity Retail Ireland describes onward sales to commercial operators as one route for donations not sold locally.
The question is therefore how the economics of reuse are changing. If valuable garments move to private resale while charities retain the costs of handling the rest, secondhand trade can thrive even as the organisations providing affordable clothing and funding social services struggle.



Comments