top of page

How rules meant to stop textile waste could actually harm the climate

Writer: Thomas Lundkvist
Thomas Lundkvist
5 hours ago
5 min read

A new report presented during COP31 highlights the enormous climate value of keeping clothes in use. It also raises the stakes in the debate over textile waste exports: poorly defined waste rules could put that benefit at risk.



A new report prepared for the UN climate summit COP31 in Antalya puts reuse, repair and longer product lifetimes at the centre of climate action.


Our Zero Waste Future, produced by Eunomia Research & Consulting and the Shape Foundation, estimates that ambitious reductions in material use and waste could avoid up to 149 billion tonnes of greenhouse gas emissions globally by 2050.


The central message is that preventing waste matters, but avoiding the need to manufacture new products can deliver climate benefits much earlier in their life cycle.



The report cites research suggesting that 100 second-hand garments can replace 60–85 newly produced ones. It also highlights an estimate that doubling the number of times clothing is worn could reduce the sector's greenhouse gas emissions by around 44%.


These are estimates drawn from earlier research, not new measurements. Their significance lies in the potential climate benefits of extending the useful lives of existing clothes rather than producing replacements.


The report also highlights Ghana's Kantamanto market as an example of large-scale reuse, where traders, tailors and repairers give imported clothing further economic and practical value.



Meanwhile, international regulators are considering tighter controls on textile waste exports. A central concern is that large quantities of unusable clothing are shipped to poorer countries under the label of second-hand goods.

But the scale of that problem remains uncertain.


Reuse News has examined the research behind widely repeated waste estimates and found that the available evidence does not establish how much imported clothing goes directly to disposal without being reused.


The distinction matters. Clothing that is cheap, damaged or initially unsold is not necessarily waste. Some of it can still be repaired, resold or used.



If regulations treat reusable clothing as waste, they could reduce the volumes available for continued use.


That could mean more clothing being discarded and greater demand for newly manufactured garments, potentially increasing emissions instead of reducing them.


The COP31 report does not assess proposed textile export restrictions or calculate their effects. But its findings make the climate consequences of any measures that restrict reuse an important question.



Preventing genuine waste exports is a legitimate environmental objective. But the potential benefits of tighter controls must be weighed against the risks of disrupting existing reuse systems.


That requires reliable evidence of how much unusable waste is actually exported, clear distinctions between waste and reusable goods, and an assessment of what happens to clothing that can no longer reach second-hand markets.


The new COP31 report puts that question into a wider climate context.

The issue is not only how much textile waste new rules might prevent. It is also how much reuse they could put at risk — and what losing that reuse would mean for the climate.



IN DEPTH: The climate consequences of getting textile waste definitions wrong


The climate implications of the textile waste debate extend beyond the question of how much unwanted clothing arrives in importing countries. They also depend on what happens to garments that might otherwise remain in use. That distinction is central both to Eunomia's new climate analysis and to Reuse News' examination of the evidence behind proposed controls on used textiles.


Why waste is not the same as low value

Clothing can be unsuitable for resale in one market and still be useful in another. A worn or damaged garment may be repaired, altered, cleaned, sold at a lower price or reused in a different form. The commercial value of an item to an exporter, a wholesaler or a market trader is not necessarily the same as its remaining usefulness to the person who eventually wears it.


This creates a crucial distinction between physical quality, saleability at a particular point in the chain, and actual disposal. None of these categories can automatically stand in for the others. Nor is everything shipped as second-hand clothing necessarily reusable.


Reuse News' reporting from second-hand markets in Africa has shown why the fate of low-priced garments deserves particular scrutiny. What matters is not merely whether an item looks poor by European grading standards or remains unsold with one trader, but whether it is eventually used, repaired, passed on or discarded.


What the export-waste evidence can, and cannot, establish

Estimates of textile waste in importing countries often describe different things. Some concern clothing judged unusable when a bale is opened. Others include garments discarded after they have been worn, repaired or traded locally. Still others use surveys or observations from a particular location. These measures cannot simply be treated as equivalent estimates of waste present at the point of import.


This distinction is especially important when findings from individual markets are used to characterise international trade as a whole. To establish the share of exported clothing that is waste rather than reusable material, a study must make clear what it counts, when an item is assessed, which destinations it represents and whether subsequent reuse is followed.


Reuse News has questioned widely circulated claims about the scale of direct waste exports because the evidence reviewed does not establish a representative share of imported garments that is immediately discarded without use. It means the size of the problem, as defined in that way, remains insufficiently established.


Where policies may restrict shipments of reusable goods alongside waste, this uncertainty has practical consequences. The volumes of genuine waste prevented, and the volumes of potentially reusable clothing affected, are both relevant to judging whether the intervention delivers a net environmental benefit.


How much new production does reuse actually replace?

Eunomia's report, Our Zero Waste Future, argues that climate policy must look beyond managing discarded materials. It emphasises the emissions embedded in extracting raw materials, manufacturing products and replacing them, and calls for the climate benefits of reuse, repair and waste prevention to be better recognised.


Its global estimate of up to 149 billion tonnes of avoided CO2-equivalent emissions by 2050 is a modelled potential across multiple sectors and material-efficiency measures. It is not a calculation of the benefits of second-hand textile exports, and should not be interpreted as such.


For clothing, the decisive question is displacement: when someone buys a second-hand garment, does that purchase avoid a new one? The answer depends on consumer behaviour, garment quality, price and how long the item remains in use. Reuse can deliver substantial climate benefits, but not every second-hand sale replaces a new purchase on a one-for-one basis.


The same care is needed in evaluating restrictions. If garments no longer reach an existing reuse market, they might find buyers elsewhere, enter other forms of reuse, be recycled or be discarded. Some consumers might buy new clothing instead; others might not. The climate outcome depends on these real-world responses, not simply on the number of garments prevented from crossing a border.


The missing test for textile export restrictions

A credible environmental assessment therefore needs to examine both sides of the equation: how much harmful waste a measure would prevent, and how much beneficial reuse it might displace. It must also consider local disposal costs and pollution, transport emissions, alternative treatment in exporting countries, and the social importance of access to affordable clothing and jobs in second-hand markets.


Eunomia does not conclude that proposed textile export controls are harmful. Its contribution is to show why the potential emissions avoided by keeping products in use belong in the climate calculation. Reuse News' investigation raises the next question: are the evidence and definitions used to justify new controls sufficiently robust to protect that benefit while addressing genuine waste?


Source: Eunomia Research & Consulting and Shape Foundation, Our Zero Waste Future (2026): https://eunomia.eco/reports/ourzero-waste-future-lower-carbon-materials-economy-2050/

Comments


bottom of page